Are Islamic Banks really Islamic?

The last couple of years have witnessed a dramatic rise in the number of "Islamic" banks in the country. And I am pretty much sure that coming months & years will witness the arrival of new "players" on the scene too. But the question here is, are the Islamic banks really Islamic or is it just another way of emotional blackmail to facilitate the transfer of money from the pockets of normal people to the pockets of shareholders of those banks?

Some of you may ask, why am I being so pessimistic? Let me try to explain my point of view. Do you feel a difference between how an Islamic bank deals with its customers compared to conventional ones? Well, the answer in majority of the cases is in negative. Both of them charge their customers & usually there is not much difference in the amount except here they call it profit & over there they call it interest.

Here they have more paperwork to test the patience of customers so they get more "ajr" or reward from God for their patience while the conventional banks are comparitively better when it comes to customer service. The test of patience starts the moment you enter inside to open an account and continues all the way to you trying to utilize one of their financial "services". You don't believe me? Check this post by someone who had to endure that patience test.

Common sense says the customer service in Islamic banks should be better than conventional ones because their profit margins are higher but unfortunately that is not the case. Poor customer service makes them more unIslamic than Islamic. I think the only major difference is that here they have Shari'a boards comprised of religious scholar to give their bank an "authentic Islamic" feel.

Do you agree or disagree with my arguements? How has been your experience with an Islamic bank? Do share your thoughts :-)

Share this post!

Bookmark and Share

9 comments:

nisa said...
This post has been removed by the author.
Arab Lady said...

DG

You already know the hell I’m still going through…from 23rd March till today I’m struggling & what makes me go nuts is that no body calls, no body follows up, nothing…!

You wana know why I choose an Islamic Bank? It’s the reason you stated

“Shari'a boards comprised of religious scholar to give their bank an "authentic Islamic" feel.”

"authentic Islamic" feel” is the reason!

Dino$ said...

What is truelt ISlamic these days? Some charity organizations take the money donated and use it for their own personal convenience. You can never know what is really islamic and what isnt.

So we use islamic banks rather than a ny other bank and we trust that they are really islamic. God know our Niya and that we are are doing are best to avoid Ribba. Whether they are just giving us the islamic feel or the real deal, we are doing our part the best way we can.

:)

Dubai Guy said...

Nisa: Salam to you too :-)

From whatever I have heard, I think the Islamic banks in Malaysia have done a tremendous job & I believe they are the ones responsible for popularizing the concept in rest of the world.

I really like that concept of Pilgrims Fund, I wish Islamic banks in our part of the world also become more active on the social front.

Glad to see you back after a long time :-)

Arab Lady: And Islamic banks really know that people will flock to them if they give them that "authentic feel". Hope your problem has been solved :-)

Dino$: No, I don't think we as consumers are doing enough, not just in islamic banking but everything. Thats why we are easily taken for a ride by the clever "businessmen". Either the banks start acting really Islamic, otherwise it would be better if they removed the word Islamic from their name.

Thanks for sharing your thoughts :-)

hemlock said...

i'm in conventional banking, and a lot of "islamic" transactions come my way, includinging sukuks, murabaha financing structures etc.
the BEST part is, pricing is stated as "EIBOR/LIBOR + profit rate"
when clearly, EIBOR/LIBOR are both interest rates offered on AED/US$ placements.

and i take them to my boss, and i always ask him, how is this islamic, when:
a) your base rate is clearly the normal interest rate, and
b) youve fixed income over a period of time, and are NOT sharing the risk?

but then, what do i know. i dont have a white beard and i dont wear a turban.

Petite For Life said...

I disagree for banks using two different banking principles Islamic and non-Islamic banking as I feel it is fooling innocent people. God only knows the truth if it is really Islamic or not.

Dubai Guy said...

Hemlock: Your last sentence really made me laugh :-D

Unfortunately, the religion has been hijacked by two types of people. Both of them are using it for commercial gains, one group is busy cashing in on the "terrorism" boom while the other is making the most out of the current "economic" boom.

And rest of us, the common people, are mere spectators either we don't know or we are too busy to make our ends meet that we don't find time to think about anything else.

God help & guide us. Btw, thanks for supporting my point with a real life example :-)

Petite for life: If I am not wrong, I believe you are a banker too. Do you have the same "Islamic" banking pheomenon growing in Oman too? :-)

Petite For Life said...

Dubai Guy,
Sorry, just saw your comment, yes I am Banker, Oman doesn't have any Islamic banking as Central Bank of Oman (CBO) doesn’t want to have Islamic banking; but an Omani bank has opened a branch in KSA as Islamic banking.

^bewitch u^ said...

i never believed in this anyway..my arguement to many is:

if islamic banks charge profti rates, then how come they state the 'rate' eg: 5.25% before they ever see the value of the car?
also, profit is never fixed, then how come they fix it over a period of 4 years?

Also, if im buying it on credit then isnt it true that accordingly to an ayat from Surah Al baraqarah, the borrower shud be given a flexible payment method and if he cant pay, he shud be given more time or his money left in Allah's sake!?

I asked an ISLAMIC BANK sales rep who was looking at my proposal when i wanted to buy a car abt the extreme case of me defaulting and his reply was 'after 2-3 cheques are bounced, the car is seized'...not once did he say that the bank will investigate the nature of ur default and then decide as to forgive u the price or take a small penalty.